Are surface mount or through hole connections more reliable for safety critical applications?

Factors like safety certifications and margins of error are more important when it comes to safety critical applications, e.g. aerospace. Lots of content online have showed the pro and cons of SMT and THT. But is there a straight-forward winner between these two?

While not a definitive answer, every recent (last 20 years) military and space product I’ve worked on has been built using SMT (Surface Mount Technology).

There were some exceptions for individual components, but that was more because the part was only available in the through-hole package, and not for any reliability advantage.

Sometimes, particularly for larger packages, we have applied an adhesive under the package or an epoxy to the corners. But that was only done when the structural analysis showed it was needed.

None of these applications were for what I would call extreme acceleration environments, such as a cannon-launched shell (a smart munition). But they do have to survive launch and stage separation pyrotechnical shock, and many thousands of temperature swings.

Finally, many components are just not available in through hole packages. In those cases ways are found to make them work in the given environment.

Leaded parts are always preferred where large number of temp excursions are involved. Even though it was SMT, because of the fine lead pitch, it could not be solder automatically and required a trained operator to hand solder it down.

Read More: Industrial Electronics PCB

#PCB Assembly

Picture of Oliver Smith

Oliver Smith

Oliver is an experienced electronics engineer skilled in PCB design, analog circuits, embedded systems, and prototyping. His deep knowledge spans schematic capture, firmware coding, simulation, layout, testing, and troubleshooting. Oliver excels at taking projects from concept to mass production using his electrical design talents and mechanical aptitude.
Picture of Oliver Smith

Oliver Smith

Oliver is an experienced electronics engineer skilled in PCB design, analog circuits, embedded systems, and prototyping. His deep knowledge spans schematic capture, firmware coding, simulation, layout, testing, and troubleshooting. Oliver excels at taking projects from concept to mass production using his electrical design talents and mechanical aptitude.

What Others Are Asking

Has anyone had good/bad experiences with particular PCB-mount thermocouples?

I need to design a circuit board with a connector I can plug a standard thermocouple connector into. And, I am aware that when you connect thermocouple wires to copper traces, you create junctions of dissimilar metals that can cause errors if the junctions are at different temperatures.

Read Detailed Advice From Blog Articles

Will Li

PCB Assembly Process: A step-by-step Guide

PCB assembly refers to the process of assembling all electronic components such as resistors, transistors, diodes, etc. onto a printed circuit board, and the assembly

The Essential Guide to PCB Controllers
Will Li

The Essential Guide to PCB Controllers

PCB controllers enable the smarts in electronics of all types, from tiny wearables to industrial robots. These ingenious chips act as the brains of countless

A Complete Guide to PCB Mounting Holes
Will Li

A Complete Guide to PCB Mounting Holes

What Are PCB Mounting Holes? PCB mounting holes refer to the holes that are drilled through the printed circuit board (PCB), so the board can

Scroll to Top